Blog

Once tenants suspect mold, they quickly find a confusing marketplace of testing options: $15 petri-dish kits at the hardware store, online DNA dust tests, spore-trap air sampling, and full inspections costing hundreds of dollars or more. Many people spend money on the wrong test, get a result they cannot interpret, and end up no closer to getting the problem fixed.

As a law firm that handles only mold cases, we review mold reports every day. Here is a plain-English guide to the most common testing methods and what they can and cannot tell you.

First Question: Do You Even Need a Test?

Not always. The California Department of Public Health has taken the position that visible water damage, damp materials, visible mold, and mold odor are enough to identify a problem that should be corrected, and that routine measurement of mold is not required to make that decision. In other words, if you can see or smell it, you already know there is a problem. (Read more about what musty odors mean.)

Testing becomes valuable when you need to:

  • find hidden mold behind walls or under flooring;
  • show the extent of contamination beyond what is visible;
  • document conditions for a landlord, insurer, or court; or
  • confirm that remediation was actually successful.

Home Test Kits (Settle Plates)

These kits involve leaving an open dish of growth medium in a room and seeing what grows. The problem is that mold spores are present nearly everywhere, indoors and out. A settle plate will almost always grow something. It cannot tell you where the mold is coming from, how much is present, or whether indoor levels are abnormal. We rarely find these results useful.

Air Sampling (Spore Traps)

A professional draws a measured volume of air through a cassette, which a lab analyzes to identify and count spore types. Indoor samples are compared to an outdoor sample taken at the same time.

Strengths: Air samples can show when indoor spore types or counts differ meaningfully from outdoors, and they can reveal “indicator” molds associated with water damage, such as Stachybotrys and Chaetomium. (See common molds in water-damaged buildings.)

Limits: An air sample is a snapshot. Results vary with weather, activity, time of day, and whether the HVAC is running. Mold hidden inside a sealed wall cavity may not show up in room air at all. A “normal” air sample does not rule out a mold problem.

Surface Samples (Tape Lifts and Swabs)

A sample of suspected growth is taken from a surface and examined in a lab. This confirms whether a stain is actually mold and identifies the type. It is simple and useful, but it tells you only about the spot sampled.

ERMI and DNA-Based Dust Tests

The Environmental Relative Moldiness Index (ERMI) uses DNA analysis of settled dust to identify and quantify 36 mold species, producing a score that compares the home to a national sample. A shorter version, HERTSMI-2, focuses on a smaller group of species associated with water damage.

ERMI was developed by EPA scientists as a research tool. The EPA has cautioned that it has not been validated for use by the public to make decisions about individual homes, and courts have reached different conclusions about how much weight ERMI results deserve. ERMI can be informative as one piece of a larger picture, but a tenant should not rely on an ERMI score alone to prove a case.

What a Quality Mold Inspection Includes

The most persuasive evidence usually comes from a qualified, independent indoor environmental professional who does more than collect samples. A thorough inspection typically includes:

  • a visual inspection of every room, closet, and cabinet;
  • moisture mapping with meters and, often, thermal imaging;
  • identifying the water source (roof, window, plumbing, HVAC);
  • targeted sampling, including wall-cavity samples where appropriate;
  • photographs tied to each finding; and
  • written conclusions and remediation recommendations consistent with industry standards such as IICRC S520.

Learn more in What Does a Mold Inspector Do?

Choosing an Inspector

  • Look for credentials from recognized indoor environmental organizations.
  • Avoid conflicts of interest. Be cautious when the company testing for mold also wants to be paid to remove it.
  • Ask what the report will include. A single page of lab numbers with no inspection findings is of limited use.
  • Keep the full report, including the lab chain-of-custody pages and photographs.

Who Pays for Testing?

Landlords sometimes hire their own inspector, and you are entitled to ask for a copy of the results. If you pay for an independent inspection and your landlord is later found responsible, the cost can be part of your damages. Talk to an attorney before spending money. We often help clients identify the right type of inspection for their situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an ERMI test accurate?

ERMI measures what it measures, the DNA of specific molds in dust, but it was designed for research and is not a stand-alone diagnostic for an individual home. It is most useful alongside a physical inspection.

Can mold be present even if an air test comes back normal?

Yes. Hidden mold in wall cavities or under flooring may not show up in room air samples taken on a particular day.

Should I test before contacting a lawyer?

Not necessarily. A mold attorney can help you choose the right testing so you don’t pay for results that won’t help your case.

Let Us Help You Read the Results

A report full of spore counts and species names can be overwhelming. We can help you understand what your mold report means. Thompson Injury Law serves tenants throughout Southern California, including Irvine and Orange County. Call (619) 615-0767 for a free consultation.

This article is for general information only and is not legal or medical advice.

Mold Testing for Tenants: ERMI, Air Samples, Home Kits, and What Actually Holds Up in a Mold Case

Once tenants suspect mold, they quickly find a confusing marketplace of testing options: $15 petri-dish kits at the hardware store, online DNA dust tests, spore-trap air sampling, and full inspections costing hundreds of dollars or more. Many people spend money on the wrong test, get a result they cannot interpret, and end up no closer to getting the problem fixed.

As a law firm that handles only mold cases, we review mold reports every day. Here is a plain-English guide to the most common testing methods and what they can and cannot tell you.

First Question: Do You Even Need a Test?

Not always. The California Department of Public Health has taken the position that visible water damage, damp materials, visible mold, and mold odor are enough to identify a problem that should be corrected, and that routine measurement of mold is not required to make that decision. In other words, if you can see or smell it, you already know there is a problem. (Read more about what musty odors mean.)

Testing becomes valuable when you need to:

  • find hidden mold behind walls or under flooring;
  • show the extent of contamination beyond what is visible;
  • document conditions for a landlord, insurer, or court; or
  • confirm that remediation was actually successful.

Home Test Kits (Settle Plates)

These kits involve leaving an open dish of growth medium in a room and seeing what grows. The problem is that mold spores are present nearly everywhere, indoors and out. A settle plate will almost always grow something. It cannot tell you where the mold is coming from, how much is present, or whether indoor levels are abnormal. We rarely find these results useful.

Air Sampling (Spore Traps)

A professional draws a measured volume of air through a cassette, which a lab analyzes to identify and count spore types. Indoor samples are compared to an outdoor sample taken at the same time.

Strengths: Air samples can show when indoor spore types or counts differ meaningfully from outdoors, and they can reveal “indicator” molds associated with water damage, such as Stachybotrys and Chaetomium. (See common molds in water-damaged buildings.)

Limits: An air sample is a snapshot. Results vary with weather, activity, time of day, and whether the HVAC is running. Mold hidden inside a sealed wall cavity may not show up in room air at all. A “normal” air sample does not rule out a mold problem.

Surface Samples (Tape Lifts and Swabs)

A sample of suspected growth is taken from a surface and examined in a lab. This confirms whether a stain is actually mold and identifies the type. It is simple and useful, but it tells you only about the spot sampled.

ERMI and DNA-Based Dust Tests

The Environmental Relative Moldiness Index (ERMI) uses DNA analysis of settled dust to identify and quantify 36 mold species, producing a score that compares the home to a national sample. A shorter version, HERTSMI-2, focuses on a smaller group of species associated with water damage.

ERMI was developed by EPA scientists as a research tool. The EPA has cautioned that it has not been validated for use by the public to make decisions about individual homes, and courts have reached different conclusions about how much weight ERMI results deserve. ERMI can be informative as one piece of a larger picture, but a tenant should not rely on an ERMI score alone to prove a case.

What a Quality Mold Inspection Includes

The most persuasive evidence usually comes from a qualified, independent indoor environmental professional who does more than collect samples. A thorough inspection typically includes:

  • a visual inspection of every room, closet, and cabinet;
  • moisture mapping with meters and, often, thermal imaging;
  • identifying the water source (roof, window, plumbing, HVAC);
  • targeted sampling, including wall-cavity samples where appropriate;
  • photographs tied to each finding; and
  • written conclusions and remediation recommendations consistent with industry standards such as IICRC S520.

Learn more in What Does a Mold Inspector Do?

Choosing an Inspector

  • Look for credentials from recognized indoor environmental organizations.
  • Avoid conflicts of interest. Be cautious when the company testing for mold also wants to be paid to remove it.
  • Ask what the report will include. A single page of lab numbers with no inspection findings is of limited use.
  • Keep the full report, including the lab chain-of-custody pages and photographs.

Who Pays for Testing?

Landlords sometimes hire their own inspector, and you are entitled to ask for a copy of the results. If you pay for an independent inspection and your landlord is later found responsible, the cost can be part of your damages. Talk to an attorney before spending money. We often help clients identify the right type of inspection for their situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an ERMI test accurate?

ERMI measures what it measures, the DNA of specific molds in dust, but it was designed for research and is not a stand-alone diagnostic for an individual home. It is most useful alongside a physical inspection.

Can mold be present even if an air test comes back normal?

Yes. Hidden mold in wall cavities or under flooring may not show up in room air samples taken on a particular day.

Should I test before contacting a lawyer?

Not necessarily. A mold attorney can help you choose the right testing so you don’t pay for results that won’t help your case.

Let Us Help You Read the Results

A report full of spore counts and species names can be overwhelming. We can help you understand what your mold report means. Thompson Injury Law serves tenants throughout Southern California, including Irvine and Orange County. Call (619) 615-0767 for a free consultation.

This article is for general information only and is not legal or medical advice.

Website developed in accordance with Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.2.
If you encounter any issues while using this site, please contact us: 619.615.0767